Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.
Talking your way into or out of a speeding ticket
Do you know why I pulled you over? It's the question you hate to hear on a road trip and there is no right answer. In most cases, you know very well why you've been pulled over: you were driving too fast. But is it best to immediately admit it and apologize; play dumb and say something like, 'I'm not sure, was I going to fast?', make an excuse for why you were speeding, or go the denial route and tell the officer you have no idea why you were pulled over?On a recent family road trip, I was pulled over just fifteen minutes away from my destination, after a seven hour drive with two toddlers raising hell in the backseat. I was frazzled and just couldn't wait to get there. The officer asked me the obligatory question that all highway patrolmen in the U.S. seem to ask and I froze. My mind processed his query as though it were rhetorical and didn't require a response.
"Do YOU know why I pulled you over," he repeated.
I took stock of the situation and blurted out a response.
"Well, we've been in the car all day and my kids have been driving me crazy, asking, 'are we there yet?' in fifteen minute increments," I explained. "I just wanted to get there."
The officer claimed I was going 70 in a 40. I was caught in a speed trap- a short little stretch of road where the limit dips down drastically for no apparent reason. It was a busy four lane highway and there were no shops or homes in sight. Just a reduced speed limit.
I should admit here that I'm no scofflaw. But on highways, I usually drive about 5-10 m.p.h. over the limit, and quickly lose patience with people who drive in the left lane at or below the speed limit. Somehow, the idea that the left lane is for passing seems to be lost on an increasing number of drivers in the U.S. And don't even get me started on people who are driving slowly in the far left lane and then, when you pass them, their head is staring down at an electronic device.
As the officer went back to his patrol car, I was pretty sure he was going to give me a ticket, but thought he might reduce it to 55 or 60. Those hopes were soon squashed as he came back and handed me a ticket for the full Monty, 30 over the limit. D'oh.
My wife, who once sided with a cop who gave me a ticket for going 42 in a 30, scolded me for not answering the police officer's- do you know why- question on the first try.
"I thought it was a rhetorical question!" I said, repeating my lame defense.
"The police don't ask rhetorical questions," she said. "He might have given you a break if you'd at least said something."
Maybe so. But maybe not. What do you say when you get caught speeding?
[flickr image via Highway Patrol Images]
The officer claimed I was going 70 in a 40. I was caught in a speed trap- a short little stretch of road where the limit dips down drastically for no apparent reason. It was a busy four lane highway and there were no shops or homes in sight. Just a reduced speed limit.
I should admit here that I'm no scofflaw. But on highways, I usually drive about 5-10 m.p.h. over the limit, and quickly lose patience with people who drive in the left lane at or below the speed limit. Somehow, the idea that the left lane is for passing seems to be lost on an increasing number of drivers in the U.S. And don't even get me started on people who are driving slowly in the far left lane and then, when you pass them, their head is staring down at an electronic device.
As the officer went back to his patrol car, I was pretty sure he was going to give me a ticket, but thought he might reduce it to 55 or 60. Those hopes were soon squashed as he came back and handed me a ticket for the full Monty, 30 over the limit. D'oh.
My wife, who once sided with a cop who gave me a ticket for going 42 in a 30, scolded me for not answering the police officer's- do you know why- question on the first try.
"I thought it was a rhetorical question!" I said, repeating my lame defense.
"The police don't ask rhetorical questions," she said. "He might have given you a break if you'd at least said something."
Maybe so. But maybe not. What do you say when you get caught speeding?
| Admit guilt and apologize. | |
|---|---|
| Play dumb. Ummm, was I going to fast? | |
| Play dumber. No idea, why did you pull me over? | |
| Make up an excuse and hope for the best. |
[flickr image via Highway Patrol Images]
Filed under: North America, United States
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Jeff Feb 13th 2012 5:27PM
I've heard the reason an officer will ask you this question is to get you to admit guilt. Now, how you choose to answer is up to you. I think it's best not to be vague or give an evasive answer, but don't conclusively admit you were breaking the law either.
Tim Feb 14th 2012 1:09AM
I've been pulled over 6 or 7 times for speeding and once for not stopping at a yield sign (WTF?) and only ticketed once... for speeding. They were pulling a bunch of people over and got me with the airplane.
Most the time, I just look terrified, so I'm not sure why I get let off. lol.
Malaycobra Feb 14th 2012 10:42AM
I have a theory. I was once let go by a cop in rural Tennessee who had waited long after his shift had finished solely to catch ME.
They have to go back to the car and write down everything that was said, in case you choose to go to court.
I got nervous, and started blurting out an excuse (in my English accent) that was filled with 5 syllable words.
My theory is that he knew he couldn't spell them, let alone repeat them, so he gave me a pass.
Dave Seminara Feb 14th 2012 3:00PM
Looks like there's an overwhelming response for the "admit guilt" vote option. But does that help you get out of the ticket or are people voting that way just because they like to be honest?
Ericka Feb 21st 2012 8:36PM
The degree to which I surpass the speed limit increases according to the relate-ability of my excuse. Am I going 20 over because I've had to pee for 40 miles? When the cop pulls me over, I'll tell him so.