Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.
Proposed casino near Gettysburg National Park denied license
The National Parks Conservation Association is applauding the decision of the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board to deny a license to a proposed casino near Gettysburg National Park. The Board felt that the gambling establishment, which would have opened less than a half-mile from the park, would be at odds with the solemn historical legacy and family friendly environment at Gettysburg.The proposed casino sparked a great deal of debate in the communities surrounding the park. It was believed that it would bring a much needed boost to the local economy and provide new jobs, but opponents called the plan an insult to soldiers that fought and died there. The Mason Dixon Resort & Casino was to include 600 slot machines and 50 table games in its bid to lure visitors through its doors.
The decision comes as the park kicks off a series of events to commemorate the 150th anniversary of the American Civil War. The Battle of Gettysburg is seen as the definitive turning point in that war, when Union forces turned back an invasion of Confederate troops, led by Robert E. Lee. It is believed that both sides combined for more than 51,000 casualties over the three day battle, which ultimately led to the North claiming victory over the South. President Lincoln traveled to the site some months later to dedicate a national cemetery there. His Gettysburg Address would become one of the most famous speeches in history.
So what do you think? Would a casino so close to Gettysburg diminish the historical events that happened there? Would it be an insult to those soldiers or is the need for economic development more important than that legacy? Personally, I'm glad that the casino was voted down. In my opinion, there are plenty of places to build a casino further away from a place that should be seen as hallowed ground.
[Photo credit: National Park Service]
Filed under: Activism, Arts and Culture, History, Learning, North America, United States, News












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Aleida Apr 17th 2011 2:06PM
I agree with you. They could easily build a casino a decent distance away that would still create jobs and help stimulate the economy. They don't need to deliberately place it so close to national history.
freddy Apr 17th 2011 2:23PM
yea, put it by 3 mile island. i can see the quaint town shops selling t-shirts with General Lee playing a slot machine. please preserve these sacred grounds, they're dissapearing too fast
LOLOL Apr 17th 2011 4:20PM
What a shame people THINK that casino' are going to "save" a town from debt. There's a casino on just about every corner in America. Now you can have a blast while losing your life savings in a casino.
J.E.B. Apr 17th 2011 2:18PM
I'm sure if they had their way, they would have that stupid casino right in the middle of the battlefield over the graves of so many brave men who fought and died there. I commend the Pennsylvania gaming Control board for denying a license to this outfit.
GEORGE Apr 17th 2011 5:04PM
BUYING A LOTTERY TICKET IS GAMBLING ALSO.
carlos Apr 17th 2011 7:00PM
No S !
SJ Apr 17th 2011 3:11PM
Too bad the gaming commission wasn't in a position to deny that eye sore that is called a visitor center that now takes up so much of the land. You can't go anywhere on the park that it does not ruin the vista. It is like having a Wal-Mart in the middle and about the same size.
Joseph Apr 17th 2011 2:55PM
At least with the Gettysburg NAtional Park near the casino people would have something to do after losing thier money. Wouldn't be a wasted trip!
John Q Apr 17th 2011 3:28PM
Good. The casino doesn't belong there. In fact Vegas and Atlantic City would be enough gambling for this country. The multitude of gambling boats and casinos on Indian reservations should be shut down immediately. They do nothing except vacuum the pockets of the poor and make the casino owners rich. They do nothing to create real jobs and they have yet to improve schools or communities.
Joseph Apr 17th 2011 3:17PM
Maybe they should put a casino in Washington D.C. near the Senate and House Office Buildings.
This way they will know where ti find our elected representatives when they are supposed to be in their offices working.
Ned Sheats Apr 17th 2011 4:11PM
As far as I am concerned lets open up gambling everywhere, tax the winnings ar 50% and dont allow deductions for losses. Pay of the National debt in 2 years I bet.
And oh yes. please quit whining about gambling being so cruel to the poor. If they want to gamble they will do horses, sports pools,or pitch pennies in the hallway.
Either you take responsibility for your actions and their results or you dont. Its not up to me or anyone else to tell them how to live their lives....as long as they arent hurting anyone in the process.
Derrell Apr 18th 2011 3:54AM
If they want to put anything there , it should HONOR all Veterans . NO casino , We paid a high price for our freedom , do not throw it away . Yes , I am from the South but I served America witout being prejucided . Too many now think Miltary is hateful . They do not even think of what the miltary does for them . Thank you , Derrell, A veteran .
lita Apr 17th 2011 5:13PM
If you tax the winnings, then you damn sure better allow writing off of losses. (It's done for investments which is also a form of gambling, since you can't possibly no the outcome. Of course, we don't call that gambling; it is more honorable.) It's called fair play--something missing in the tax code already. And no, I'm not a gambler.
Hugo Apr 17th 2011 4:19PM
When opportunity knocks you must answer one way or another. It would be nice if the people that wanted to build the casino could relocate their plans to at least five miles away but that isn't as easy as people think it is and sometimes it's not possible. Yes, it would create jobs and revenue for a local region that is hurting financially. But as many of you have stated in your comments, "This is hallowed ground." I have mixed feelings though, about "hallowed ground". One thing you learn in life is that "nothing is that sacred that the living will go without". Every civilization that has taken over another one has built over that other one's so-called "hallowed ground". It has never really stopped us before and when a really pressing need to build over hallowed ground comes about again in the future you can be sure we will build over, under, and through it. It will all depend on who and how many are in "need".
Jim F Apr 17th 2011 4:31PM
As I read some of the comments and suggestions some folks have I can't believe the feelng they have against a casino in the Gettysburg area. I used to love to go to Gettysburg and shop, eat and enjoy the battlefield but recent years has brought greed and stupidity to much of the town. You used to be able to shop and buy some decent priced souveniers and clothing and most of it was made in the USA.
Try to find it now! Most of the stuff is made in China or other countries. My point to this is. The National Park Conservation Association is looking blindly at something that would bring in revenue (which the to sorely needs) and forgetting about the men and women who gave their life for Gettysburg. People are tired of coming to a town that has gotten away from it's history. Selling junk and raising the price of the museum tickets isn't going to get relief for the towns dwindling monetary needs. I hope an appeal is filed and you have to eat crow. Our forefathers were some of the best gamblers around and I don't thinks they'd give a damn one way or another about a casino in Gettysburg
mya Apr 17th 2011 4:27PM
Think about what the soldiers would "want". I mean, if they were alive (here or then) you don't think they'd be into going to a casino and gambling?
Bud Maxwell Apr 17th 2011 4:36PM
There is no greater "Gambling Casino" in the world than the Capital Building in D.C.! You place your bets on a Representative to help win something of gain to us all, and invariably lose your shirt in the process. Odds are against us all!
Edgar Longenecker Apr 17th 2011 5:01PM
Sure.... And then, wimp out for the Mosque Brigade construction crew... on Constitutional, grounds, of course... with the aid of the ACLU....
Bob Apr 17th 2011 5:05PM
I am not a history buff. I would not even think of going to Gettysburg unless they had other things to do. 6 Flags Park, Casino, Race track, or something I would enjoy. Thanks, but I think I will go to the shore fror vacation.
Larry Apr 18th 2011 1:00PM
Even lacking an interest in History, it is a fantastic place to see. It could humble you to see the graves. So many who are buried there have no name listed. Lost generations.