Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.

Hold the dog, please. China's proposed ban on sale of dog and cat meat

by Laurel Miller (RSS feed) on Mar 12th 2010 at 3:00PM

Most people will agree that dog is man's best friend. In parts of Asia, however, it's also what's for dinner. The consumption of dog and cat meat by humans is practiced in parts of China, Vietnam, Korea, and the Philippines. Cat is eaten in parts of China and South America. The times they are a-changin', however, because the Chinese government is considering legislation that would make eating dogs and cats illegal there, in part because of how the practice negatively impacts overseas tourism.

The Chinese government has signaled a willingness to take the meat off the market. To avoid upsetting international visitors during the Beijing Olympics, officials ordered dog meat off the menus at local markets. Officials in Guangzhou have warned vendors to stop selling it ahead of the Asian Games, which will be held there later this year.

Professor Chang Jiwen of the Chinese Academy of the Social Sciences is one of the law's top campaigners. "Cats and dogs are loyal friends to humans," he said. "A ban on eating them would show China has reached a new level of civilization." Anyone else finding irony in that statement, considering 2007's massive pet food recall -- the result of melamine-tainted exports produced in China?

While inconceivable to most North Americans and Europeans, these animals have been used as food for thousands of years, usually for purported medicinal purposes, although poverty also plays a role in some countries or regions.

While owning dogs and cats for house pets isn't the norm throughout Asia, it's certainly common in China. But the roles of ingredient and animal companion never cross: special meat markets exist that cater exclusively to the sale of dogs and cats for the meat trade. Chang cautions, however that there is always a chance they're someone's lost or stolen pet.

Regardless of how you feel about dining on dog, the most critical issue regarding this "specialty meat" trade is animal welfare. The animals can be kept in horrifying conditions until they're sold at market, and subjected to cruel, inhumane treatment. And before you condemn certain cultures as barbaric, take a second to think about the conditions in puppy mills and factory farms in the United States. Livestock sold at auction for the commercial meat market, and live meat animals and poultry at slaughterhouses may also be subjected to inhumane treatment. The U.S. government is cracking down on these abuses, but factory farms don't appear to be going away anytime soon.

The ban on eating dog and cat meat is part of a larger proposal to toughen laws on animal welfare. Individual violators could face up to 15 days in prison and a small fine. Businesses found guilty of selling the meat risk fines up to 500,000 yuan ($73,500.)

The legislation is gaining support from China's growing number of pet owners. With living standards rising and disposable income growing, more Guangzhou residents are investing in house pets.

Meat vendors and specialty restaurants, however, see their livelihoods at stake."The dogs you raise at home, you shouldn't eat," says Pan, a butcher who also declined to give his first name. "The kind raised for eating, we can eat those."

According to the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, the law prohibiting cat and dog meat could take as long as a decade to pass.

Gallery: "Gross" Food

Filed under: Activism, Food and Drink, Stories, Asia

Search Travel Deals

Reader Comments (Page 4 of 4)

DMW Mar 16th 2010 9:33AM

Any culture that goes around eating dogs and cats when they can easily raise and eat the "conventional" chicken, pig, and cattle is NOT sick, just plain EVIL! I get a "big bang" over their explanations/rationalizations for eating cats/dogs.....Its "medicinal", "its a good elixir", etc. For all the rationalizations that I have heard, all you have to do is insert RAT instead of DOG in front of medicinal and the Chinese would "buy that explanation" if emphasized, publicized, and preached by their medicine men who also sell bear organs and tiger organs to promote "good health, healing, and virility!" My question is this.....for hundreds of generations and even NOW, where is THEIR medical community doing to show to the "backwards public" that there is NO evidence whatsoever that eating dogs or cats promotes and delivers ANY health claims whatsoever! Dog and cats are protein, but then again, so are rats and rabbits! I think "tradition" has overstepped the boundaries or compassion, ethics, and common sense! But really bugs ME is the WAY these cats/dogs are killed or butchered! It is a common practice to "hang" the animals in order for the meat to be "more tasty!" When it comes to compassion, and rightful stewards of natural resources, and animal rights and conservation (except for the panda!) the Chinese have no history or conscience!

Previous 20 Comments