Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.
Hold the dog, please. China's proposed ban on sale of dog and cat meat
Most people will agree that dog is man's best friend. In parts of Asia, however, it's also what's for dinner. The consumption of dog and cat meat by humans is practiced in parts of China, Vietnam, Korea, and the Philippines. Cat is eaten in parts of China and South America. The times they are a-changin', however, because the Chinese government is considering legislation that would make eating dogs and cats illegal there, in part because of how the practice negatively impacts overseas tourism.
Professor Chang Jiwen of the Chinese Academy of the Social Sciences is one of the law's top campaigners. "Cats and dogs are loyal friends to humans," he said. "A ban on eating them would show China has reached a new level of civilization." Anyone else finding irony in that statement, considering 2007's massive pet food recall -- the result of melamine-tainted exports produced in China?
While owning dogs and cats for house pets isn't the norm throughout Asia, it's certainly common in China. But the roles of ingredient and animal companion never cross: special meat markets exist that cater exclusively to the sale of dogs and cats for the meat trade. Chang cautions, however that there is always a chance they're someone's lost or stolen pet.
Regardless of how you feel about dining on dog, the most critical issue regarding this "specialty meat" trade is animal welfare. The animals can be kept in horrifying conditions until they're sold at market, and subjected to cruel, inhumane treatment. And before you condemn certain cultures as barbaric, take a second to think about the conditions in puppy mills and factory farms in the United States. Livestock sold at auction for the commercial meat market, and live meat animals and poultry at slaughterhouses may also be subjected to inhumane treatment. The U.S. government is cracking down on these abuses, but factory farms don't appear to be going away anytime soon.
The ban on eating dog and cat meat is part of a larger proposal to toughen laws on animal welfare. Individual violators could face up to 15 days in prison and a small fine. Businesses found guilty of selling the meat risk fines up to 500,000 yuan ($73,500.)
The legislation is gaining support from China's growing number of pet owners. With living standards rising and disposable income growing, more Guangzhou residents are investing in house pets.
Meat vendors and specialty restaurants, however, see their livelihoods at stake."The dogs you raise at home, you shouldn't eat," says Pan, a butcher who also declined to give his first name. "The kind raised for eating, we can eat those."
According to the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, the law prohibiting cat and dog meat could take as long as a decade to pass.
Gallery: "Gross" Food
Related:
* 8 great bug-eating videos from around the world
* 10 great Anthony Bourdain "No Reservations" clips
* The 25 greatest cities in the world for drinking wine
* The 24 greatest cities in the world for drinking beer
* The 20 greatest cities in the world for foodies
Filed under: Activism, Food and Drink, Stories, Asia













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
Martha Stewardess Mar 13th 2010 5:23PM
As a passionate pet lover and animals rights activist, Thank You China for considering this change for the good of mans best friend.
Tails are wagging world-wide with this news.
Al Schrader Mar 14th 2010 9:04AM
I'm a farmer. I don't eat pets. What is incredibly foolish abouth this is that dogs, cats, etc are very poor livestock. They don't eat corn or wheat or straw. They only eat expensive meat trimmings or parts. A dog can eat $150 worth of this in 6 months. They grow ridiculously slow - can take 8 months to market size. A chicken takes about 10 weeks, in comparison. It's not cost effective. I guess if you steal pets it might be.But of course, that makes you a thief & eventually you yourself will become dog meat...Al-
MrDoughnut Mar 14th 2010 6:21AM
The abuse of Cats and Dogs must end or these countries should be wiped off the face of the Earth..
jeff Mar 14th 2010 6:45AM
Lovely, japanese kill these beautiful mammals, the wales and these idiots eat pets. What is the matter with these asians anyhow? We know the other god awful things they eat but no need to go on. Oh yeah I don't want to hear about culture either.
CINDI Mar 14th 2010 9:37AM
THESE ARE VERY, VERY SICK PEOPLE, TO ME IF THEY EAT A POOR HELPLESS PET THEY'D EAT THEIR KID'S, WE NEED TO STOP TRADING WITH THESE SICK'OS, THIS STORY JUST TURNED MY TUMMY, WE HAVE TWO CHICKEN'S A PARKEET A GOOSE A DOG AND 2 CAT'S, ALL WELL TAKEN CARE OF, AND OUR FAMILY PET'S WITH NAMES, OH YOU PEOPLE OVER THER ARE VERY, VERY SICK.........
Beth Mar 14th 2010 11:42AM
I suppose you would have strengthened your credibility had you used the proper spelling of a word when you condemned and entire country.. Whales are mammals and swim in the ocean. Wales is a country that is part of the UK and I think if "the Asians" were eating them there would be a larger outcry....just saying...
jeff Mar 14th 2010 1:44PM
Beth how dare you correct me!.......you are correct. whales not. Wales. Actually, I know better. I won't even give you an excuse. But I assure you I do have one!
Apologies. My 3 dogs are safe as are my neighbors as I am not hungry today.
Ann Mar 14th 2010 8:17AM
It is about time they decide to stop eating dogs and cats and I hope they stop skinning them alive. Does this mean they will start eating the Siberian Tigers, they feed chicken bones to and then they die?
Randy Mar 14th 2010 8:39AM
I have some K-9s that would love to eat that commie!!! Country!!! And are we going to keep buying and buying from their until they own us economicaly??? STOP! Try!
Dave Mar 14th 2010 8:41AM
Eating an intelligent, sentient animal is barbaric and borders on cannibalism and I have nothing but contempt for anyone who eat cats and dogs. Shame on China, Vietman, Korea and the Philippines. And shame on those contemptible subhumans in the US who run puppy mills and sell puppies and kittens in pet stores.
Anyone who has ever owned a cat or dog, loyal and loving companions, would certainly agree.
jeff Mar 14th 2010 1:54PM
Sub-human, what a great way to put it. Strange people to say the least. This from a people who all wore Mao-Se-Tung outfits not all that long ago. (Beth, did I spell that right)?
dice6060 Mar 14th 2010 8:45AM
I go to China on business and have eaten both cat and dog. Other than being a little greasy, it's great.
Angie Mar 14th 2010 9:10AM
Amen to your reply !!!!
dice6060 Mar 14th 2010 9:15AM
Almost forgot, French Poodle is the tastiest.
Adri Mar 14th 2010 9:22AM
So glad they are taking steps to end this inhumane and inHUMAN practice. The farming, stealing and eating of cats and dogs is disgusting and wrong.
ary Mar 14th 2010 9:35AM
why would people feel upset, because over here they are considered pets?? Are they any different to use for meat other cultures consider a main entree like we do steak,etc.? Stop being hypocrites VEGETARIANS AND VEGANS IS THE ONLY OPTION : IT IS THE HUMANE ALTERNATIVE. GO GREEN - GO VEG
Norma Mar 14th 2010 9:36AM
why can't china just drop off into the ocean?? they are a gross nasty bunch of human flesh. their products are cheap and do not last but STUPID PEOPLE STILL BUY THE CRAP AND YES YOU CAN FIND PRODUCTS NOT MADE IN THAT HORRIBLE PLACE. YOU JUST HAVE TO LOOK. obama needs to move to china since he is such a big fan..
Bill Mar 14th 2010 9:38AM
First off, I own a dog, and have owned a cat before. I could never imagine eating them. However, after stating that, get off your high horse people, you have never lived in the culture, so you can never "judge" properly. What happens in one country and culture might not work in another. This is almost the same as saying my religion is better than your religion, so I believe you shouldn't have the right to practice yours.
Al ot of people preach tolerance, but when it comes down to it, they don't practice what they preach.
wong-foo-kingcat Mar 14th 2010 3:06PM
Well. I hate to be a hypocrit, I must confess, I have tried raw puss, I would not go near it if it was not cleaned and trimmed. so who am i to say anything?
I certainly would not eat it in a restreruant, or anywhere in public.
but hey, who am I to say anything? I can't imagine a dog.. I am not that type..
eeew.. i get the shivers just thinking about that..
wong-foo-kingcat Mar 14th 2010 3:13PM
I Think i should add, I was trying to make light and be funny on an issue that i truly believe is disgusting. But, because it is disgusting to me, does not affect the rights of others in thier own country. Maybe I was not funny to some. and I apologise to anyone I might have offended.