Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.
Plane Answers: The Frontline episode regional airlines don't want you to see
I've always been a big fan of PBS's Frontline. It's obvious that they study a subject before they report on it. And as any pilot knows, that can be a rarity in the often hyped television coverage of the airline industry. Frontline has tackled specific airline subjects in the past and I've always found them to be accurate and insightful. I'm looking forward to the episode tonight called "Flying Cheap" that may just expose the disparity in pay and working conditions at the regional airlines.
Major airlines have long used separate carriers as a firewall of deniability while playing them off each other to secure the lowest bid. They control the scheduling of these companies, but leave the maintenance and operational responsibility to the regional.
A few carriers, such as Delta and American wholly own and have control over their regionals, but they still contract with other small airlines to some extent.
After the response from last week's Plane Answers about the NTSB reaction to the Colgan 3407 accident in Buffalo, it will be interesting to see if this PBS Frontline episode spurs enough public interest to cause some changes. PBS has provided an eleven minute excerpt below of the show that may give you an idea of what direction the program is taking tonight.
From the Frontline press release:
In "Flying Cheap," FRONTLINE investigates the deadly airline crash of Continental 3407 in Buffalo, NY, and what the crash reveals about dramatic changes in the airline industry. The rise of the regionals and arrival of low-cost carriers have been a huge boon to consumers, and the industry insists that the skies remain safe. But many insiders are worried that now, 30 years after airline deregulation, the aviation system is being stretched beyond its capacity to deliver service that is both cheap and safe.
Frontline examines the rise of low-cost regional carriers-who now account for more than half of all domestic US flights-and asks: Is the aviation system being stretched beyond its capacity to deliver cheap, safe service? Watch on air and online beginning Tuesday, February 9 at 9 p.m. on PBS (check local listings).
In the eleven minute excerpt from tonights program, there's a gem of a quote from Roger Cohen of the Regional Airline Association, the group that lobbies on behalf of these smaller carriers involved in code sharing.
When confronted with the low pay and how it represents an untenable economic position for the junior pilots, Roger, who looks like he recently came back from an extended Caribbean vacation, defends regional pilot pay with this:
"I just checked the web this morning-you can get a hotel room near the Newark airport for $50 a night." He proudly claims.
Roger doesn't realize that, at $21,000, this would represent between 20% of a line-holder and 50% of a reserve pilot's potential take-home pay. At these rates, even a crash pad looks too expensive and the crew lounge becomes far more tempting.
I had to run some numbers. On a typical one hour and fifteen minute flight, a Dash 8 burns $2,900 worth of fuel. A copilot in his fifth year at Colgan earns $29 an hour, or $36.25 on that flight. (Source: Airlinepilotcentral.com) Maybe it's time to rethink that pay scale. Management doesn't realize that if they gave this pilot the tools (and incentive) to fly just 1% more efficiently, they could nearly double that copilot's salary.
But that just touches on pay. Be sure to watch the excerpt below to catch a VP of operations at a regional that comes up with an innovative way to falsify records in order to get a pilot to fly past his FAA mandated sixteen hour duty day:
While not every regional airline pilot earns these kind of wages or flies with this kind of pressure, tonight's episode just might highlight a few companies that have been driving the pay and working conditions lower for much of the industry. Every pilot I know will be watching. But maybe passengers should take a look at this, as well.
UPDATE:
PBS has posted the entire Frontline episode, "Flying Cheap" online to view here.
Do you have a question about something related to the pointy end of an airplane? Ask Kent and maybe he'll use it for the next Plane Answer's Plane Answers. Check out his other blog, Cockpit Chronicles and travel along with him at work. Twitter @veryjr
Filed under: Airlines, Plane Answers













Reader Comments (Page 3 of 3)
cldade55 Feb 10th 2010 12:29PM
This is why I drive, rather than fly regional carriers. If it is too far to drive my own car, I fly to the nearest airport serviced by a major carrier and rent a car.
delta Feb 10th 2010 12:42PM
i worked for this airline for 28 yrs i was a former Western airlines employee I WILL NEVER FLY DELTA EVER they are cost cutting like i never seen in 28 yrs in the buisness it used to be the best company to work for when they took over Western airlines back in 1987 i feel sorry for the Northwest employees just wait and see what they do to you guys
Mark Feb 10th 2010 1:11PM
I saw the normally objective Frontline episode about airline safety last night and could
not believe the bias shown towards the airlines.Only two things come to mind: if plane
travel is so unsafe why do we not have more accidents? Also,who has the most to lose
when an accident does occur?
acovell Feb 10th 2010 1:43PM
Just one of the many reasons I have stopped flying. I don't go anywhere that requires a flight. If I can't drive or take the train or a bus to a destination, I don't go.
Bob Hulsizer Feb 10th 2010 6:48PM
About two years ago we had a short flight from Detroit to Columbus. Maybe a 40 minute flight at the most. We were on a Northwest flight and out of the blue I heard what sounded like a shotgun blast on the left side of the A/C. I turned to my wife ans very quietly said,"I believe we just lost an engine". Yes ,I was correct because the crew did almost a flat turn back North. The pilot came on the I/C and stated that we had lost an engine and we were returning to Detroit. We were less than 10 minutes from touchdown in Columbus. Even though Detroit is a hub it was not the smartest thing to fly 30 minutes back to Detroit on one engine rather than land at Columbus. There were many people on board that flight that had no idea what was going on when the pilot announced we lost an engine. I wonder how many said,"Oh my god one of our engines fell off". I wrote a letter to Northwest stating how I felt about the way they handled the situation and received no response. We fly quite a bit but not on Northwest/Delta. We stay with Southwest if they fly where we want to go. Thank you!!
Richard Feb 11th 2010 11:25AM
If you look at the situation from the angle of risk, it appears that air travel is the safest.
"The odds of being killed during a scheduled airline flight are about one per million -- nearly four times greater than the odds of being killed in an automobile ride. But most car trips are for far fewer miles. Per passenger mile an automobile ride is 10 times more likely to result in fatality than an airplane journey."
Source: http://www.benbest.com/lifeext/causes.html#data_usa
Airplane accidents are spectacular events. Auto accidents are not. As I remember, we kill about 45,000 Americans per year by auto. Makes airlines, of any kind, look real safe.
thomas j gorton Feb 17th 2010 6:45AM
I am not a pilot and not well versed in aviation, but my understanding about the Colgan crash was that the pilot pulled back on the stick when warned instead of pushing on it. Completely separate from the pay for regional pilot issue is the fact that all pilots know that when you point the nose down, even a little, you gain air speed. This fundamental tenant of flight may have saved Flight 3407 had the pilot reacted properly. The BA 777 that landed short of the runway at Heathrow in January 2008 was saved by the pilot when, at an altitude of 600 feet, he lowered the nose when the engines did not respond to commands for more thrust. The plane barely made it over the fence but the passengers and crew were saved from a crash into a neighborhood by the slight gain in air speed.
As far as regional carrier regulation, it certainly needs an overhaul. And the pay for the pilots needs to be seriously increased. There is no price on flight safety and I'll be pleased to pay more.