Gadling

I have the same question as Darryl, why couldn't they just have continued on to Toronto, I would think landing with a flat tire would be the same in either airport...At least right now when the weather is somewhat the same.

Maybe this is a good question for Kent of Cockpit Chronicles.

The reason the Aircraft was placed in a holding pattern was that at the time of the tire failure the Aircraft was in an Emergency situation. Safety dictates that the Aircraft land as soon as possible at the NEAREST airport capable of handling the EMERGENCY landing of which has the best emergency response, fire and rescue teams available. The Aircraft (Boeing 737-800) dumped its fuel immediately upon notifying LAX and Center controllers, who cleared it for an IMMEDIATE EMERGENCY LANDING. At this point it is at the discretion of the pilot (who is responsible for the safety of the passengers and aircraft) to make the decision of WHEN it's the safest for him to land. In this case, he dumped fuel to the absolute minimum to reduce the risk of fire in the event of a failed landing. His circling was directed by the air traffic controllers who were aware of his fuel situation and were routing him over areas of the least aircraft and ground population. At all times the pilot had the choice as to when he was going to land and was cleared for an emergency. Realize that in this situation, they're no room for a mistake. There's no second chance. He did a great job facing an emergency. JC1

i could not agree with your comment more. i work for an airline, and i'll tell you i can't beleive some of the things that are so easy, they make so hard....so 2 thumbs up for you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

FAA protocol is if there is a known emergency - get to the nearest airport and start making prepartations accordingly. it takes time to get emergency personel in place. it takes time to diagnose the problems and prepare for a safe landing - forget about being productive - safety above all else. For what other reason is airline travel the safest transportation in the world!