Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.
Another disabled traveler horror story: Delta passenger with muscular dystrophy forced to crawl off plane
Earlier this month I posted on a husband who had to carry his wheelchair-bound wife onto a Ryanair flight after the airline failed to make sure the proper equipment -- in this case, an Ambulift -- was available at the plane during boarding. The Ambulift never showed up.While we can debate all day whether the airline's crew in this case could have done something else to help, what we cannot debate is that amid all this discussion about what is and what is not in the job description of airline crew, it is undeniably a part of the job to make sure that disabled passengers are accommodated during the boarding and de-planing process.
A woman named Julianna, who has muscular dystrophy, says she found herself having to crawl down the steps off a Delta Airlines flight July 20 in an effort to make a connecting flight after it took the airline more than 30 minutes to produce a wheelchair and lift.
Her flight landed in Atlanta at 7:30 p.m. Her connecting flight departed at 8:05 p.m. Her wheelchair showed up at...8:05 p.m.
At one point, Julianna says flight crew members told her she might end up making the connection if she stopped standing around waiting for help. How busy they were trying to track down that chair is unclear.
Her ordeal continued for the next several hours. Delta agents haggled about whose job it was to push Julianna around in her wheelchair as she got re-ticketed (obviously she missed her connection) and assigned to a new gate. The Delta ground crew members who were supposed to be on call for such a task apparently weren't answering their stations.
When Julianna reached her final destination, West Palm Beach, again Delta did not have a wheelchair waiting, and she crawled onto the shuttle bus, she says.
No doubt there will be finger pointing about whose responsibility it was to help Julianna, and who dropped the ball. There always is during these incidents of apparent incompetence. The flight crew? The ground crew?
Perhaps Julianna is exaggerating the incident, as irate travelers can. But either the wheelchairs were waiting for her, or they were not.
If, as it appears, they were not, then Delta Airlines dropped the ball, regardless of who specifically you pin it on.
There are few excuses I can think of for not having wheelchairs waiting for passengers who need them.
Forced to crawl, Julianna is justified in venting her disgust, as she does in a letter to Delta CEO Richard Anderson excerpted on the consumer advocacy Web site The Consumerist.
Filed under: Airlines, Airports, Consumer Activism




Get a WordPress.com Blog



Reader Comments (Page 1 of 9)
Secret Asian Man Jul 30th 2008 2:31PM
Well, that's just messed up.
As a person who also has Muscular Dystrophy and travels alone from time to time, I'd be furious if I had to crawl out of a plane. It is degrading. It's bad enough people already literally look down on in our wheelchairs, but to be seen crawling? Indescribable.
I'm thankful of having the fortune of encountering nothing but reasonable to outstanding service when I travel. And I have nothing but empathy for this woman.
Until we know the whole story, I don't know who to blame. As a disabled traveler, you have to learn to plan and arrange everything ahead of time. That means calling your airline 24 hours before your departure to notify them that you are a disabled passenger and to inform them of your needs, including a transfer chair and to have your chair ready for you at the gate.
You also need to arrive early so you have enough time to inform the check-in attendant one last time of what you'll need. This is critical. Because at that point, they can change your seats to sit closer up front, notify the freakin' control tower of your arrival, so they can tell the crew to look out for your chair, they can notify your destination or transfer city of your intent to be there so they are prepared. And they can get you boarded first, which what you're supposed to.
Do not wait for the last minute to tell your flight attendant as your plane is taxing into the gate that you'll need an aisle chair or whatever. While most F/A have the foresight to ask you before the plane even takes off of what you'll need at your arrival, it's really not their job to arrange for things outside the plane. That's the check-in counter attendant's job.
I've traveled countless times with both my manual and electric wheelchair, with companions and alone, and I've never had any problems. Hell, I flew American Airlines, one of the crappiest airlines in terms of customer satisfaction and I got excellent service. I get to skip the long lines in check-in because I was allowed to use the First-Class counter, got my seat bumped up to First-Class because Coach was full but hardly any in First-Class and they want me up front anyway. They notified everyone of my intent to fly including my transfer city and destination. So no-one was caught off guard and I had the option to use my own chair at the transfer instead of using the airport's. And one my return home, my flight was going to be delayed, which meant I'll miss my last bus home. But nope, the nice lady put me on a different flight, non-stop, on Northwest Airlines and I made it home on-time.
Disabled people have to make it easy for others to help them. Ironically, they need to be considerate of other people who can help them. Don't barge in the last minute making demands and waving the ADA flag if they can't get assistance right away. So, it may be that the woman in the article simply didn't allow the airline enough time to prepare. Either way, it still sucks for her.
maddalen Jul 30th 2008 5:37PM
I'm really surprised. Two years ago, my husband ruptured his patellar tendon, and could barely walk, and I had to get him back to NY from Atlanta. I switched our flight to Delta, in order to get a direct flight back to NY, and the Delta folks could not have been more helpful. They helped me arrange, with the Atlanta airport, to have a wheelchair right at the curb, and an attendant to wheel him to the airplane door. All he had to do was hobble to his seat. In NY, a wheelchair was waiting at the plane door, and we were taken all the way out to the curb. I'm astounded by this story, as Delta could not have been more accommodating or nicer to us during this very tough time.
Karin Jul 30th 2008 5:49PM
If you are disabled you are just as ignorant as they are, I know everybody in their right mind knew that this lady needed help, the pilot could have carried her of the plain, or somebody could have helped her, they just stan around anyway. To have to crawl out of an airplain that is a crying shame. I don't like to sue people, but this would be a lawsuit of all lawsuits.
cathy Jul 30th 2008 7:04PM
That is not a legal connection. She must have made two different reservations to get 2 connectign flights so close together. So, it's her fault that a wheelchair couldn't get there in order to satisfy her speedy needs. Wheelchairs and their attendants are in demand and sometimes one passenger takes more time than the airlines had anticipated. One cannot expect servic eon the minute unless one pays fo rit. I am sure there are ways to reserve immediate service at airports in advance, but one would have to pay.
This soudns liek a story with the passenger expecting more than a passenger ought to expect .
By the Way .. that mother with the autistic dhild adn the other disabled one todl reporters and everyoen that they were left with nothing.. but Southwest refunded them the cost of the second leg.
be careful for sensationalism.
Stanley Pilny Jul 30th 2008 7:38PM
Yes you are lucky in your travels. Others not so. It is not the airline but some of the idiot employees. I never in 50 yrs of travel have had a bad incident. But this year I have made 2 trips full of mixups and frustration that I dont think I will travel by plane anymore. I have a trip comeing up but with AMTRACK.
john Jul 30th 2008 10:01PM
I am disappointed that her fellow travelers did not help her. Delta has employees who no longer see the customer as the most important part of the business. What most Delta employess are interested in is their retirement plans or how much money they are making - my most recent experience is evident. I was on time - the plane landed on time - I got to the connection with a full 15 minutes to spare to find out that the plane was gone-this caused me to get in late and in turn caused all my plans to be pushed further out - they did not honor my ticket because of their mistake - and it cost me an extra nights stay. DELTA is not my air line.
Brandi Jul 30th 2008 3:31PM
I feel extremely sad for the woman, however 30 min between a flight? Give me a break. If you can't book a flight for at least an hour inbetween then don't book it, especially when you need wheelchairs. THOSE are hard to come by. It was no one's fault, it's an airline and she chose to do the crawling.
Nada Jul 30th 2008 4:07PM
The passenger probably planned enough time between flights but the first flight was delayed.
Morgan Jul 30th 2008 5:31PM
How dare you. Have you ever been to Atlanta Airport?It's like a ghost town when you need help and they have a really bad problem with the check in. I know it's a really busy airport but they really need to improve on the people that work there. When you ask them a question they get an attitude and treat you like you are stupid and act as if you have sinned severely for even approaching them. I live between Bham airport and Atlanta airport and I'd rather go to Bham anyday and have them land me in another airport other than Atlanta. They are the ones that need to improve. Someone with Muscular Dystrophy or and other disability should never have to depend on themselves to get through the airport. It's the airport's and the flight carrier's responsibitlity to know who is getting on that plane. Also, sometimes its very difficult to get a flight with a longer layover to give you enough time to get through the airport especially ATL and still make it in time to where your destination is.
cathy Jul 30th 2008 7:04PM
I agree with Brandi.
Also the pilot does not have that in his job description. NO airline crew does. Where in the world does anyone think that the crew is supposed to carry passengers up and down steps and concourses? That is some nerve. He was very smart to NOT do it. because then it would have been.. carry me to my flight which leaves in 25 minutes now... and his JOB would not get done.
Jay Lawrence Jul 30th 2008 4:13PM
I will try to avoid taking DELTA airlines whenever possible in the future. That story is simply disgusting. And the airline execs scratch their heads and wonder...and even offer incentives to attract more people to fly! Obviously, they cannot give basic care to the passengers they already have!
Don Lawrence Jul 30th 2008 7:07PM
way to go Jay! Love, dad
Bev Jul 30th 2008 4:19PM
Doesn't surprise me at all that this happened. My mother-in-law had a similar experience with American Airlines. We even arranged for wheel chairs when we booked the flight 2 months in advance. We called ahead 24 hours before the trip just to make sure she would be accomodated. Did American Airlines provide wheelchair service? NO!! Their customer service rep even told us she should have taken a bus instead of a plane! Disgraceful to say the least.
Lucy Jul 31st 2008 12:16AM
American told her she should have taken a bus instead of a plane??? Wow .... that's terrible !!
kim Jul 30th 2008 4:18PM
I cannot imagine how difficult it is to travel with a disability of any kind, however keep in mind that the airlines do not own the wheelchairs and have no control over them. The airport (in most cases) is ultimately responsible for transporting all passengers in need of assistance. I have to believe she was very upset, however why is she crawling onto a shuttle bus, was there no one there to assist her either? Delta does not control the shuttle buses. It is always helpful to travel with a companion if you are in need of special assistance and allow plenty of time for connections, shuttles, ect....There are also laws in place to protect people while traveling who are disabled and they will fine the airliines if they feel they were at fault.
Judy Collins Jul 30th 2008 4:21PM
I too am a Disabled traveler. I usually take Amtrak or Greyhound when I travel. When I travel I tell them in advance that I need help boarding. And for the most part both have been quite helpful. The last trip I took on the bus, they didn't bother to board me until the bus was ready to pull out of the station. Then someone had to move to allow me to sit in a ADA seat. Not to mention my embarassment at having to board late. I was to be boarded before the rest of the passengers. So I can feel the pain these two women have had to suffer while traveling. I do not fly for the simple fact that I have metal plates and screws in my body and I for one don't like being strip searched even though I have a note from my doctor. I would suggest these women find alternative ways to travel. The bus lines and Amtrak go out of thier way to help their customers whether disabled or not.
ya mama Jul 30th 2008 4:19PM
I think the first comment hit the nail right on the head.
Daryl Jul 30th 2008 4:20PM
I worked at an airline and the pilot always called in when they were 20 minutes out and reported any "specials" which included children flying alone, people in wheelchairs, or any other people with special needs. We had the chairs waiting at the plane when they came in. It wasn't the airline that was responsible for getting the wheelchair though it was the sky caps at the airport. But the airline had to call the sky caps.
Steph Jul 30th 2008 6:25PM
Interesting. Something similar happened once when I flew United- our flight from Chicago was delayed for well over an hour while the crew members both on the plane and at the counter bickered about whose responsibility it was to help a woman in a wheelchair from the previous flight get out of the plane.
Roger Jul 30th 2008 4:26PM
One of the most outrageous stories I've heard about the deteriorating service of American's airlines. If all of it is substantiated, every employee involved in this disgusting treatment of a disabled lady should be fired. Given the type of airline executives running things today, however, don't bet on anything at all happening.