Bolshoi in Russia: Stumbling between Devoloped and Developing
Here is a laundry list of my observations based on traveling in Russia and talking to people here. I am stating in advance that this post might offend people (believe me, I've already taken a ton of heat for my prior posts, even if some were meant to be tongue-in-cheek). Since the terms "first" and "third" world no longer carry the same meaning they once did (after the "second" world vanished with the disappearance of the Soviet Union,) I will use politically correct terms "developing" and "developed" instead.
I will start by saying that I have never been to a country where you are so frequently thrown from luxury to poverty in a matter of blocks or minutes (sorry, NYC, you're not #1 in this regard). One minute, you think that you are in one of the most developed countries on the planet. The next minute, you feel...completely the opposite. The gap between the rich and the poor is wide in America, too. But it's a little different here. There is no visible middle class in Moscow, so you get thrown from "high" to "low" very abruptly. Top reasons that make Russia look like a developed country:
I'll also remind you, dear readers, that this is based on a relatively short trip, focused on Moscow and St. Petersburg, plus some background research into statistics.
- Arts. Museums have amazing collections; orchestras have fantastic musicians.
- Design. Although related to Arts, but Russia's young designers (interior, product, etc.) deserve their own category. They do really cutting-edge work here.
- Prices in big cities (Moscow and St. Petersburg). Moscow is the most expensive city in the world. No really, it is.
- Nightlife. As described in one of my previous posts, the club scene is dazzling.
- Education. Very high literacy level (Russia's 99.4% rate beats America's). Russians are avid readers. Good schools (although I've heard rumors it's pretty easy to buy a college diploma here).
- Luxury. Premium cars and fashion brands are seen everywhere. Heck, an enormous Rolex ad sits opposite the Kremlin.
- Sushi. The sushi wave has hit Russia big time. It's good and it's one of the most reasonably-priced things to eat.
- Good coffee. You can get a good espresso so many places now.
- Technology. You can pay all your bills through electronic kiosks. How cool is that?
- Wi-Fi. It is not difficult to connect to free Wi-Fi. Even Red Square has Wi-Fi spots.
- Personal safety. You do feel safe here.
- Low birth rates. On par with the rest of the West, Russian women postpone having babies and only have one, maybe two. (Not saying that's necessary good, but that it mimics the developed world.)
- Secular society. Although religion (Russian Orthodox), is an important part of the society, it doesn't enter politics too much. (Same here: this is not a judgment.)
Top reasons that make Russia look like a developing country:
-
Can't drink tap water in most places.
-
Service is generally quite poor. Certainly not compatible with the cost of things.
-
Plumbing. Showers are smelly (lack of traps) and in many places you can't throw toilet paper into the bowl, and are told to put it in the bin next to the toilet.
-
Lack of international signage. Reading Cyrillic is a must, in restaurant menus or public transport.
-
Pollution. Air is terrible in Moscow and not great in St. Pete's. Cars still use leaded gas here. And, that gas is cheap.
-
Russian passport doesn't exactly "open doors" to many developed countries
-
Human rights abuses. Lack of care for the disabled or physically challenged (as of last year, there was not even a law prohibiting discrimination). Gay parades are prohibited. On-going freedom of press issues. (In the interest of brevity, I will spare you the citations in this post, so please feel free to do your own research.) Foreigners must register, like in many "police states." Foreign tourists still have to register with the police if they want to stay more than three business days. This is a pain in the butt, but some hotels will do it for you.
- Poor healthcare. CIA estimates that 1% of Russian are HIV-positive, while Russia "is not counting." (Official estimates are less than a third of what international bodies estimate, and Russian health officials scoff at international estimates.) Cancer treatment is virtually non-existent for those who can't afford it, and survival rates are a fraction of those in the West.
- Low life expectancy. An average Russian man can expect to live 59 years.
- Smoking. Sixty-plus percent of adult population in Russia smokes. That certainly doesn't help their low life expectancy. It doesn't help that cigarettes are cheap. A pack starts at less than a dollar. A pack of Marlboros will set you back less than $2.
Opulent displays of wealth, real or fake. The popularity of excessive jewelry and leopard-print clothing cannot go unnoticed. - Rudeness and inability to form functioning lines. My pet peeve. I always thought Czechs were rude. It must be an East European thing.
- High emigration rate. A high percentage of people leaving a country with no intentions to come back...it's a bad sign.
- No middle class. It's either Bentley or a Lada. Or, it could also be a "Volsche". One billionaire had an old Volga (another Russian car) put on the chassis of a Porsche Cayenne and had the car decorated with Swarowski crystals--and a picture of Stalin-- at a cost of $1m. Call me biased, but this is easily as bad as whatever the Tsar had ever done.
- And, of course, xenophobia. Russia still remains the greatest country ever. (A least that's what you get by reading the Moscow News.)
From Russia, with love.
Filed under: Europe, Russian Federation





















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Jun 2nd 2008 @ 12:18PM
teenagertc said...
Another place where the disparity is striking is China. In Nanjing, there were high rise condos on one side of the street, and ghetto's laced with alleyways filled with dirty shacks on the other side of the street (excuse the bad sentence structure...)
Reply
Jun 2nd 2008 @ 5:04PM
TravelBot said...
Much of the world doesn't have a middle class.
In Ghana, West Africa, going from rich to poor was as easy as walking a single block. One one street The Sony Store, a block away open sewers and subsistence living.
Reply
Jun 2nd 2008 @ 5:05PM
Chris M. said...
I must know, was it your intent to write "cars here still use *leaded* gasoline"? Because you wrote unleaded which is what we use pretty much everywhere else...I'd be shocked if anyone in the world was still using leaded gasoline. ******Thanks, Chris. Duly corrected. I meant to say "leaded." Although it was officially banned by law starting in mid-2003, the practice of selling leaded gasoline is alleged to be still widespread there. Iva******
Reply
Jun 2nd 2008 @ 5:20PM
mikey said...
I studied Russian for five years and love its language, history, and literature. I've been there four times and agree with this developed/developing assessment.
My fourth trip there was as a 30 year old with friends who has never been and who don't speak Russian. It was phenomenal how frustrating it was to explain away all the "minuses" about how Russia works: the xenophobia, the lack of adaptation to tourism givens (like dual language signage), price gouging, etc. They enjoyed themselves but I was immensely infuriated at how hard it would have been for them to be independent travelers there without the assistance of someone (me) who knew the language and how to get around. I basically swore off russia after that and haven't been back for six years. The "romantic" notion of the country's craziness that I was willing to put up with as a 20 year old was gone...
Reply
Jun 2nd 2008 @ 5:38PM
Slava said...
Good insights Iva.
Slava from www.travelallrussia.com
Reply
Jun 4th 2008 @ 5:27PM
Slava said...
I am looking forward for more stories!
Slava from http://travelallrussia.com
Reply
Jun 8th 2008 @ 3:22AM
australian_v1 said...
Yeah, and we are the country that for the past 100 years:
was tottally devastated by October 1917 Revolution and civil wars (how many millions people died domestic or fled abroan I am not going to estimate). Suffice to say that Russian had population of 129 mln. around 1900, and now it`s 140 mln. - almost the same. To it also attributed communists policy of "collectivisation" in 1920-1930, with awful famine in rural areas. Stalin`s purges of 1933-1937 took away few more million lives. Gitler invasion of 1941 - 1945 took another 20 mln. as per official estimate. Modern reports vary up to 30-40 mln. human losses during WWII. Relatively peasfull Soviet period from 1945-1990 let the country accumulate some wealth. However, perestroika and glasnost collapsed Soviet Union when living standards totally went to zero. Crime, corruption, Caucasus wars, lost of all 15 Soviets Republics put Russia on its knees again. We were guilty as charged and paying concequences of 1917 revolt. After all that, we are back again, standing streight with our head up. We are gonna make it, people.
Reply