Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.
A Canadian in Beijing: FOR SALE! Live Animals (Trapped) in Small Cages

Walking along the sidewalk here in Wudaokou in the late afternoon and evening is not a passive exercise. The sidewalk markets take a wide space and transform it into a narrow, colourful corridor as vendors roll out their ware on square pieces of fabric on both sides and then call for your attention as you pass. That doesn't keep people off the sidewalks, of course, but instead draws more to this small area. As a result, congestion is intense and the going is slow. If you're not headed anywhere in particular then it's worth the stroll. (If you're trying to get somewhere on time, I suggest walking along the street!)
I have been taking in these kinds of street markets all over the city since I arrived and I've noticed one common element: there are always small, live animals for sale.
I hate to see it. Small rabbits in cages that are just slightly larger than they are with barely enough room to turn their bodies around. There are always puppies and kittens, turtles, snakes and lizards of various sizes. All of them are miserably tucked into cages or plastic cubicles and lay taking in the afternoon heat in their cells.
I can't free them and I can't save them . . .

I feel helpless and powerless walking by. I wonder who actually buys them and why. Do the rabbits become pets or food? And the reptiles must simply become pets, right?!
The huge box of baby chicks would make a lot more sense to me if this were a rural area. I can understand people having farms or small lots on which they would raise chickens for eggs and/or meat. Now, if this were the intention for the chicks, then I can understand wanting to sell them and wanting to buy them. But, here in the city? What would a person do with a baby chick here? Is it legal to keep chickens here? Something tells me that it's not, especially since almost everyone lives in an apartment.

I have seen a lot of things like this here, i.e. things about China that I don't understand and don't want to see but simply have to accept as being part of the way it is here. I know I have my cultural background that fuels my opinions and I know there's so much more to everything than meets the eye. Still, life here in Beijing has occasionally challenged my values and beliefs. I have chosen to sit back and take in the culture rather than passing judgements before I understand.

Two months later (and then some) and I still don't understand the reason for selling these small animals in this way. And, I still want to set them all free in a park somewhere... which is, of course, not the answer. Nor will any amount of discussion with a vendor change the fact that they're being sold, especially not in my third language.
About a month ago, I expressed to a vendor in Chinese that I felt sorry for the animals. I said they were "poor things" and said that their "houses were too small" (lacking the word for "cage" in my vocabulary.) The vendor just laughed at me with a look that told me he has heard it before from the foreigners and he has no time or space for it. This is his livelihood. This is his job.

Who buys them?
My friend Sarah told me that she knew two people who had bought puppies or kittens from a street or sidewalk vendor only to watch them die just a few days later. There is a compulsion to want to give one – if even just one – a safe and cage-free life and many ex-pats succumb to that urge. Apparently, these puppies and kittens are often drugged so that they appear more docile and cute while being sold (rather than active and hard to contain.) If the dosage is too high at that time that they are drugged, it eventually kills them but long after the vendor and customer have exchanged money for merchandise. I haven't heard this since, but I was horrified to hear it at all.

Back in North America, we have done lots of work to make pet stores more humane. There is often a lot of anger towards them and over time I have noticed that most people just don't trust these stores to care for the pets properly, preferring to find new pets at the Humane Society or the local pound.
So, buying live animals on the street is just another level altogether.
Now, when I'm strolling through the sidewalk markets, I just steer around the animal vendors. I can't bear to see the congestion of turtles or chicks in boxes too small for their volume. I can't bear to look at the puppies lolling in their drugged state and worry about whether or not they'll pull through into adulthood.

After driving my gaze deep into the vendors' eyes and telepathically communicating "how could you?" alongside of an amazed expression, I turn my head.
This technique doesn't make it go away, however. Maybe this post will inspire more people to ask the vendors the "why?" questions – especially those fluent enough in Chinese to carry on a conversation. Until then, I can write about it.
(And always be open to other suggestions...)
Filed under: Arts and Culture, Stories, Asia, China, A Canadian in Beijing













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Alex Jun 19th 2007 7:45AM
This is a kind of disturbing aspect of China. It's odd to see it in major cities too! What freaked my wife and I out was the "Wet Market" that we peered into in Tai-Po (suburb of Hong Kong). All the animals in cages and the slaughtering taking place on tables inside this large hall with guts all over the floor and completely dirty!
We're not vegetarians, but we didn't even go inside as it turned us right off...
Keep having great adventures!
From,
Torontoians in Dallas
Lou Jun 19th 2007 8:02AM
Well, I usually say "I wish I could see what you're seeing!"
Not this time... I'd be a blubbering mess. :-(
Louhoo
biker_frog Jun 19th 2007 9:25PM
It's sad to say but it's simply supply and demand really. If people didn't buy them, they wouldn't be sold. And I wouldn't be surprised if the pets were also eaten as well. I had a uni flatmate from Nigeria who had eaten her pet cat (in Nigeria). They had it as a pet for many years and then they ate it. I was floored! I said, "how could you eat your beloved pet!?" She simply said, "in Nigeria you don't throw away good meat." I just thought, "I'm glad that I'm a vegetarian!".
birgit Jun 20th 2007 9:59PM
Ember,
I flooded my shirt sleaves with tears while reading this post and staring at the images.
The mistreatment of animals occurs everywhere, from our neighbours' backyards to our "friendly" Circus acts. It breaks my heart. What to say?
"Mankind's true moral test, its fundamental test (which lies deeply buried from view), consists of its attitude towards those who are at its mercy: animals. And in this respect mankind has suffered a fundamental debacle, a debacle so fundamental that all others stem from it." - Milan Kundera
birgit
Stella Jun 22nd 2007 3:57AM
SO lets see Beijing made it as sexy city why? exactly? first off that is digsuting the fact that people resort to eating cats and dogs is revolting and unacceptable. Whoever supports the economic growth of eating pets and cat and dog fur trade should be slapped and pushed into a ditch. Its not onlythe fact that pets are eaten, it is also disturbing how they are treated and tortured. I will never visit China and do not have any desire to, Sexy city based on culture?? hm what part of sexy culture is eating animals exactly?
Brrasie Jun 26th 2007 12:30PM
Thanks for writing about this, Ember. The dog slaughter I wrote you about was a result of the Chinese people not being able to afford Rabies vaccinations. And three people died of rabies. So... people just went around killing people's dogs. Instead of finding a vaccine for all of them. I only know part of the story, I hope.
Pete Oct 23rd 2007 3:24PM
Hi All,
Just wanted to comment on the animals. This is all food. None are kept as pets and if you visit some of the "other" areas they will even cook your pick for you.
We can all feel disgusted about this but the fact remains this has been the worlds staple for thousands and thousands of years. No different than what we do here in the USA or North of the border, we just close our eyes to the processing part of the business.
boredwell Dec 5th 2007 2:55AM
I live in San Francisco. In Chinatown live animals are sold for food. Pigeons, chickens are routinely carried in plastic bags and taken home. Tourists, aghast at this, complained. The authorities decided the vendors could not be that blunt in their selling and packaging oflive animals. Inhumane and sadistic, were two words most often used to describe the tourists' distaste. But they are going home to die, the vendors protested. Chinese call animals "moving things" and do not have emotions about the lpast or current ifestyle of their future meal.