Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.
Just How Hard is it to Fall Off a Cruise Ship?
In the past two weeks, three people have gone overboard on cruise ships -- a drunk 35-year-old off the Florida coast, and a couple 20-somethings who've asked for the circumstances of their tumble to be kept secret. So what gives? Are you actually at risk of going overboard when on a cruise?
Carolyn Spencer Brown of CruiseCritic.com says: "It is so hard to fall overboard that when someone does go over the side, it's either because, sadly, it's a suicide attempt or it's because they're being incredibly foolish."
Douglas Ward, author of 'Berlitz Complete Guide to Cruising and Cruise Ships,' suspects "that drink is usually involved in these kind of circumstances."
Douglas Stallings, editor of 'Fodor's Complete Guide to Caribbean Cruises,' agrees, saying: "Many of these incidents involve excessive use of alcohol."
So no, you're not at risk, unless you've been getting hammered.
But not so fast. Even though statistics provided to Congress by cruise lines show that less than one in one million passengers went missing over a three-year period, organizations like International Cruise Victims still exist. These critics say that cruises are dangerous, and that -- especially when foul play is involved -- the cruise lines don't thoroughly investigate. Additionally, a recent Congressional hearing found that crime reporting on cruise ships is inconsistent.
However, in spite of these high profile incidents, chances are that Douglas Stallings is right, and "cruise ships are considerably safer than any other place you're likely to vacation."
Filed under: Paddling












Reader Comments (Page 2 of 4)
Eddie Apr 3rd 2007 11:44PM
Yes, there are fools among us even aboard cruise ships as in any area of human endevor, and they will manage to create problems for both themselves and the rest of us, no matter what we do or what precautions we take.
Someone can always find a good way to screw-up if they want to badly enough!
MIKE AND LINDA Apr 3rd 2007 11:45PM
I CAN'T REMEMBER HOW MANY CRUISES WE HAVE BEEN ON. AT LEAST 2 OR 3 TIMES A YEAR. WE LOVE THE SEA AND ALWAYS GET A BALCONY. FOR SOMEONE TO PITCH OVER THE SIDE VIA BALCONY OR PROMENADE RAIL WOULD REQUIRE MORE THAN JUST MERE NEGLIGENCE. IT WOULD REQUIRE A FEAT OF ABSOLUTE GYMNASTICS. AT MY AGE (71) I DON'T THINK I COULD GET UP THAT MUCH STEAM - EVEN WHEN HALF IN THE BAG. SO, I'M STAY-STUCK SAFE.
e Apr 3rd 2007 11:49PM
Have to diagree,We cruised Carnival 5 years ago and I leaned against a railing and it it wasn't latched.
It swung open but I caught myself.
It can happen
e
The Mully Man Apr 3rd 2007 11:53PM
A blind man couldn't fall off a ship. You'd have to be pushed off or totally wasted.
Now if it was after the election and Hillary won everyone would be jumping off the top deck.
Jill Apr 4th 2007 12:12AM
Okay. Do we really know the stats on the number of people that have "fallen" overboard? I agree that you can't really fall overboard unless you are REAL drunk. All other incidences are either suicide or thrown off by someone else. Guess what? I bet in most cases the person was thrown overboard by someone else. Drunken states most likely (both parties in most cases); but, I am not up to date on how many people have been found guilty of foul play on a cruise ship. I live in Florida and the cruise ship business is big bucks. All I am trying to say is we will never really know what happens. Not just on cruise ships. No one seems to want to know as long they are not affected. I am signing off, but I would like to end with "who is the father of Anna Nicole's baby" Oh, and one more thing. I know that Rosie O'Donnell is really starting to piss people off, but she is correct in stating that "if you really want to know what is going on in our country, you can't read or listen to our news.
Sarah Apr 4th 2007 12:01AM
what I dont understand is with the 20-something year olds lately that fell off the ship from Galveston. Were they not together in the water? The paper here (Galveston) said that one was rescued and then like 30 minutes later they found the other one. We obviously know what they were doing on the balcony.... but if they didn't fall in at the exact same time and they didn't stay near each other in the water for 4 hours....what happened? Ya think one went over and the other one jumped in afterwards??? I don't get it.
The Truth Apr 6th 2007 6:00PM
I went on a cruise in spring 2005. We had a cabin with a small balcony. The balcony railing is about 4 feet high. I'm 6'1" and the railings on the main decks of the ship are also up to the middle of my chest. Anyone would have to deliberately climb over the railings to "fall in", or have someone lift them over. Now, if you drink and are stupid, that's another story.
bob33 Apr 4th 2007 12:26AM
You would have to be intentionally trying to jump ship to get over the railing, and the people who go and jump probably want to be off the ship, and or dead. They should just be left at sea, or rescued, fined, and left at the nearest port.
Nancy Apr 4th 2007 12:37AM
I just returned Sat from my first"real" cruise (had been on a couple one day trips). I was nervous to be on a ship(they are NOT boats)for 7 days but was pleasantly surprised. I felt completly safe and very pampered and thanks to those little "patches" never felt seasick. As it happens our ship was cruising the same course as the ship where the "20 somethings" fell off. Their ridiculous and dangerous behavior had to be the cause of them falling because you cannot just fall off the railings are nearly shoulder high and the ship they were on was much larger and newer than the one we were on.Alerts went out immediatly for their search and scores of people were involved in their rescue. There was another ship from the same cruise line I was on in the same area, everyone on the 3 ships knew what happened so good luck to them keeping their secret. I agree they should have to reimburse any costs incurred to save them. for those of you who may be influenced by this and afraid to cruise, please know that most of these incidents are soley the fault of the passengers and the ships are VERY safe. I can't wait to sail again!!
Jane Apr 4th 2007 12:33AM
I took my 7 year-old grandson on an Alaska cruise last summer...the deck railing was about as tall as he was, so I would never hesitate to take a child on board. Furthermore, you can NOT "fall" over the railing...you'd have to climb up on it, and THEN you would risk falling.
Grunt Apr 4th 2007 1:27AM
I just recently was on a cruise and in order to go over you need to actually TRY to fall off. The railings are HUGE! I'm 6'4 and you see I'm still here typing and I had a room with a balcony and even leaned over the railing to look down and never felt like i was going to fall. but its just plain STUPID to sit on the rail or to be having "relations" on the rail.
Paulacruises Apr 4th 2007 1:54AM
Hey, cruise consultant weighing in here. Suzy, have you ever been on a cruise? My guess is no. On me, balcony railing is breast high. If you stay on the proper side of the railing, you will NOT go over. Toddlers are on cruises ALL the time and they are not pitching off ships. Sue, I think it's time someone asks Jennifer Hagel about kicking her husband in the crotch in the casino and flirting with other men (pretty well documented). I bet the scenario went something like this-(flirtatiously) she said "I hate his guts. You guys kill him and throw him overboard. He's got $35 thousand cash in the safe in the cabin." He was heard boasting about the amount of cash he had in the cabin..travel smart, travel often, and cruise!
Vivi Apr 4th 2007 3:23AM
Alcohol in the system is the reason for all this. One martini before dinner and one cognac after dinner and all will be reported on board at bed time.
Liz Apr 4th 2007 3:36AM
The many comments from people who admit to strolling around on a cruise blasted reminds me again of why the whole idea is so repellant. Trapped on board with hordes of over-eaters, over-drinkers crammed into an inescapable corral. Please. It sounds as appealing as a cross-country trip on a bus.
Tim Reichel Apr 4th 2007 3:48AM
I've been on seven different cruise ships and the height and configuration of the railings, including the stateroom balconies, make it nearly impossible to "accidentally" fall. It would have to be intentional or "show-off" horseplay.
Steve Apr 4th 2007 5:15AM
Having spent 21 years in the Navy, I have seen men washed overboard and have been on ships that were sent to rescue men. It is easy to go overboard on a Navy ship due to the configuration of the decks and open spaces. I have seen ocean liners and sailed once on one. There is no way any one who goes over board can say they fell off just leaning on a rail(maby if the rail went with them) they are idiots if they land in the sea from a safe ship.8 ships and 17 years at sea experance and never overboard.
Lona Apr 4th 2007 4:41AM
It's weird that this couple want HOW they fell overboard kept secret??? I heard they were trying to do some Titanic version of Leonardo and Kate Winslit... Either way they are IDIOT'S ! How freakkin stupid can they be to put themselves AND the crew who rescued them at risk because "they were screwing around!" I've been on 8 cruises and falling overboard would not JUST HAPPEN... one would really have to work at it... I too think they should be fined UP the Wazoo for the trouble they cause AND they should thank their lucky star's that they were found... As for crime aboard ships, I think this will be the upcoming problem for cruiselines.... I know one thing...I won't get a cabin with a balcony that is directly accesible to the water again... Balcony yes...but with other balconie buffering inbetween!
Lona Apr 4th 2007 4:48AM
PS: If you have never taken a cruise you should keep one VERY IMPORTANT thing in mind. Cruise ships, with the exception of maybe 2 that I know of are ALL registered outside of the USA... that means that IF you think that Cruiselines can 1) Protect you, 2) Defend you, 3) Take the same care and concern your local US Police Dept. would, 4) Are prepared for ANY MAJOR MEDICAL EMERGENCY, etc. .... YOU TRULY BETTER THINK AGAIN! You may wish to KNOW YOUR FACTS and your RIGHTS when it comes to Cruising and IF you were to have any problems aborad ship etc. Remember that most likely you WILL BE in INTERNATIONAL WATERS and it is DEFINITELY NOT THE SAME as being in the United States... And don't think because you are a US CITIZEN that its going to give you Clout or help you when you are at sea... Forget it! These ships are governed by laws outside of US jurisdiction ... KNOW YOUR RIGHTS before you cruise... it may make alter your decision....
shari Apr 4th 2007 5:40AM
personally, I do not like cruises, I prefer my feet on solid ground. Enjoying the beauty of the USA, the mountains, the beaches. Cruises are for those who want to gain about 15 lbs on their vacation
jkatt3 Apr 4th 2007 9:24PM
Tons of food, room service, more food, great entertainment, maid service, and the list goes on. What idiot would want to leave all that for cold dark water and a chance of dying? If my cruise prices go up to pay for lawyers because of your stupidity, I would like your hame address so that I can send you a bill and a "lovely" letter. Do us all a favor and stay home. The only DWI you'll get on a cruise is "dancing while intoxicated". I have MS and fall down a lot and even when drinking I haven't come close to falling overboard.I say yes to charging for rescue services, and restitution to ALL passengers who miss an excursion or flight. Responsibility rests with offenders, not the cruise lines. Who babysits you at home?