Click on a label to read posts from that part of the world.
Just How Hard is it to Fall Off a Cruise Ship?
In the past two weeks, three people have gone overboard on cruise ships -- a drunk 35-year-old off the Florida coast, and a couple 20-somethings who've asked for the circumstances of their tumble to be kept secret. So what gives? Are you actually at risk of going overboard when on a cruise?
Carolyn Spencer Brown of CruiseCritic.com says: "It is so hard to fall overboard that when someone does go over the side, it's either because, sadly, it's a suicide attempt or it's because they're being incredibly foolish."
Douglas Ward, author of 'Berlitz Complete Guide to Cruising and Cruise Ships,' suspects "that drink is usually involved in these kind of circumstances."
Douglas Stallings, editor of 'Fodor's Complete Guide to Caribbean Cruises,' agrees, saying: "Many of these incidents involve excessive use of alcohol."
So no, you're not at risk, unless you've been getting hammered.
But not so fast. Even though statistics provided to Congress by cruise lines show that less than one in one million passengers went missing over a three-year period, organizations like International Cruise Victims still exist. These critics say that cruises are dangerous, and that -- especially when foul play is involved -- the cruise lines don't thoroughly investigate. Additionally, a recent Congressional hearing found that crime reporting on cruise ships is inconsistent.
However, in spite of these high profile incidents, chances are that Douglas Stallings is right, and "cruise ships are considerably safer than any other place you're likely to vacation."
Filed under: Paddling










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
Jeff Apr 3rd 2007 8:43PM
People who jump overboard should be charged $$$$ for their rescues coz i'm sure some are wholly intentional - the runaway bride got him with a fine and community service so it stands to reason that the idiots who jump overboard are just as frivolous and flighty. The same thing goes for hikers who have to get rescued - ante up, folks - the rest of us have to ultimately pay for yer follies.
charles Apr 3rd 2007 8:44PM
Frankly I have been on many cruises and agree that a sane person even with a BAC over .08, the legal limit, will have a difficult time falling off a ship. Children who are very prone to accidents but do not drink and are not suicidal, do not seem to fall off these vessels so the boats are obviously very safe for the average person. Even spring breakers who get blasted while cruising away do not seem to fall off while they are often kill themselves on land through drunk driving incidents and trying to jump from balcony to balcony in a high rise motel after too many cool ones.
Joe Apr 3rd 2007 9:14PM
I say just rescue someone if they actually fell. If they jumped or were wasted, throw them a life preserver and forget about it; it's their fault.
Susan Apr 3rd 2007 9:21PM
I had a good laugh reading this one...The 20's couple would like their circumstances on falling overboard to be kept a secret...I cant imagine why? LOL
SUE Apr 3rd 2007 9:26PM
I TRULY LOVE CRUISING. NOW MY HUSBAND DOES ALSO. MY CHILDREN HOWEVER ARE FRIGHTENED TO BRING THEIR CHILDREN BECAUSE OF THE OVERBOARDS. THIS IS SO SAD, I DO THINK THE SHIPS CREW SHOULD BE EVALUATED FOR SOME PROBLEMS, AS WITH THE NEWLYWEDS.
elizabeth Apr 3rd 2007 9:30PM
well there was a whole disscussion on this on one of the morning radio call in shows. this guy said two verandas down this young couple were being intimate on the railing and he was amazed they hadnt fallen off the railing. maybe it was the same couple and they did fall in after he gave them privacy
johnone Apr 3rd 2007 9:35PM
IT SEEMS TO ME THAT IF SOMEONE WAS HAVING SEX WHILE ON A BALCONY SITTING ON THE RAIL IT WOULD BE EASY TO FALL OVER BOARD , ANY ONE AGREE WITH ME.
suzy Apr 3rd 2007 9:51PM
I think it is extremely easy to go overboard!The ship is open all the way around and if you have a balcony room,you can lean right over the balcony.A couple of drinks and you could go over in an instant!Frankly,I'm surprised more people don't fall overboard!
Judi Apr 3rd 2007 10:37PM
Me tarzan, You Jane, lets take a cruise :)
Judi Apr 3rd 2007 10:39PM
Me Tarzan...You Jane...Lets take a cruise
LEE Apr 3rd 2007 10:48PM
FOR SUZY -- HOW MANY CRUISES HAVE YOU BEEN ON ? UNLESS YOUR SEVEN FOOT TALL YOU CAN'T JUST FALL OVER THE RAILING EVEN IN A BALCONY ROOM. WE ALWAYS GET A BALCONY ROOM AND FOR ME TO FALL OVER THE RAILING ACCIDENTALLY I WOULD HAVE TO STAND ON THE DECK CHAIR.
AND THE RAILING ALL AROUND THE SHIP IS WELL MORE THAN WAIST HIGH SO IT'S ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO FALL OFF UNLESS YOU ARE FOOLING AROUND OR DRUNK.
PLUS WE ALWAYS TAKE OUR GRANDCHILDREN AND THEY LOVE IT.
Doug Apr 3rd 2007 10:53PM
Obviously Suzy has never been on a cruise..Imagine talking to your neighbors in the backyard the only thing seperating you is a 4 ft fence... can you imagine just out of the blue talking to them and all of a sudden you fell into there yard. That is how likely it is to happen...If this has ever happened to you then I would definitely never go on a cruise.
Gary Mitchell Apr 3rd 2007 10:57PM
My wife and I have been on several cruises and have always had a balcony and have walked the decks at all times of the day and night, including when we were "somewhat" intoxicated. We've never even come close to falling overboard. You'd have to be trying to fall overboard, or be intoxicated enough to climb up on a deck chair, or something else to get high enough to fall over the railing.
lauthehut Apr 3rd 2007 11:01PM
doug love your example....i agree been on many cruises, there is no way you just fall off a cruise ship....
Eve Apr 3rd 2007 11:14PM
I love cruising! I think it is the best and safest way to see the world! My fear is that these fools that get on a ship and drink too much and do something stupid will ruin it for the rest of us. Prices might go up to compensate for lawsuits. I believe that cruise ships can divert these incidences by installing more video cameras along open decks and as far as the private balconies, install some type of netting or awning that swings out from the bottom along the private balconies. The netting or awnings could be rolled in when not in use, then rolled out when the ship is at sea. In order for a person to go over one, they would have to stand on the rail and jump outward several feet. I would say then if they managed to hit the water, it was definately deliberate. If the boats have to stop to pick up overboard passengers, then they should be dropped off at the next port and not allowed back on ship, no refund. Also, they should have to pay a fine. If the cruise ships took this step and also printed disclaimers for passengers to sign if they "fall" off the ship, I bet jumpers would think twice about doing it. Also, they should not be allowed to board any cruise ship again.
judy Apr 3rd 2007 11:04PM
I've never been on a cruise. I'm more afraid of getting sick than falling overboard.
Mary Apr 3rd 2007 11:08PM
Let me start with that I am 33 years old and I have done 24 cruises in the last 10 years with my Husband. It is near impossible to fall over board. You have to be acting like a total ass in order to go over. For example we saw someone in 1997 having sex on the balcony which is not recommended, (People can see you). I have and do my share of drinking, and we all know when enough is enough. But I have seen it my self where some of these parents take their "KIDS" that just graduated collage in large groups on the ships and have their own staff members available to them where they just drink from the time they get up to the time they go to bed. We where a little on the noisy side and asked the father how much he had spent so far and we where told in 3 days his bar bill was almost 2,000.00 sorry but that is like 14 beers in a 12 hr time frame. Yes it was a large group, but they should of been cut off at least for a time period. The cruise ships should come up with a way to see how much an individual is ordering in either a time frame or quantity, but they should have a limit on it. I definitely agree that if someone goes over for being a ASS they should have to pay the rescue. Their are times when things happen that you cant prevent, the first cruise I was on someone had to be airlifted out for having a baby early, and their was the time we had to have the boat re routed because some idiot decided to rent a wave runner (the ships don't recommend it if it's not booked through them) but they decided to go on land where the drinking age is 18 and got loaded and got on the wave runner, and crashed into coral, and they had to be lifted out due to injuries, and we lost a day at an island which sucked.
pat Apr 3rd 2007 11:13PM
I just came home{darn} from a cruise on adventures of the sea rc and these people are nuts..falling off is impossible.being drunk and stupid is not.i wish i could cruise forever and i promise i wont FALL.
Gabe Apr 3rd 2007 11:12PM
I have been on a cruise, and am about to embark on another one. I have also been very intoxicated while the ship was moving all about. There was no way I was going to go over the railing. It's just too high, unless you climb on top of it Titanic style. I just don't see how someone can fall off a cruise ship by accident.
JMForester Apr 3rd 2007 11:37PM
Just a few years ago I was working as the counselor on a cruise ship / floating University and we had someone fall overboard. A student was drunk, it was a dark moonless night around 2am, and we were around 1,000 miles out at sea crossing from Africa to S. America. If a crew member hadn't seen the student fall from where they were sitting on the rail they would never have been found. The crew member threw several life rinsg with a strobe lights in the water to mark the spot. The stupid student actually removed one of the strobes and left the life rings behind and started swimming after the ship with the strobe in hand. Luckily they were rescued and back on ship within 45 minutes. With a blood alc. level of .2+